Brian Branch needs to learn to tackle

I’m old. I cheered for the Lions when they went 0-16. I’ll cheer for them if they win it all. But the older I get, the less I care about wins and losses and the more I just want to be entertained. And more than anything else, I want to root for good people, not just good players.

All that said, Branch needs to learn to tackle. For one, I’m tired of him lowering his shoulder instead of wrapping up just because it’s bad football. But it’s also just a bad look. He’s got a reputation around the league as a dirty player, and that didn’t just happen. And now he’s hurt himself and another Lion. I don’t wnat anyone to get hurt, and I don’t want to root for players that play out of control.

2 Likes

He took himself and Wonnum out diving in head first to hit a player that was already clearly going to ground.

He’s a great player but he’s dumb as a rock and after what happened to Jack today I hope somebody sits him down and tells him never to tackle with his head and never to hit a player who’s already going to ground.

He’ll take himself out of the league at this rate.

4 Likes

He’s never struck me as dumb, but can agree he’s undisciplined on the field at times.

4 Likes

Leading with your head is dumb. Getting kicked out of games is dumb. Missing game time due to your own actions is dumb.

Indiscipline = not thinking = dumb.

It’s annoying that in year four he’s still doing dumb shit.

3 Likes

Some guys just run hot when they play. I got to hang out with Reggie Miller a couple of times, extremely intelligent guy, but as he says you have to toe that line when you release the competitive beast. He got plenty of Ts and kicked out of a few games. Emotions run hot, and Dan and our coaches stoke that fire of disrespect. We PLAY angry. For the most part it’s a good thing, but yeah for some guys you end up with stuff like this. I still say the good far outweighs the bad with Branch.

7 Likes

If he ends up concussing himself out of the league, or into poor health after his career, then I would beg to differ.

Well, sure. If he ends up shattering his shoulder out of the league, then I would beg to differ. But you don’t make these calls on what might happen. You can say that about anyone who plays physically.

2 Likes

I’d play angry too if ny sister was a better baller than I was.

3 Likes

Leading with the head is just plain dumb. It’s bad technique, and it’s a massive health risk. Kids should have that coached out of them before high school. For me, it’s inexcusable to do that in the NFL, and doubly inexcusable when the opponent is already going to ground as per Sunday. He hurt himself and a team mate, and it’s cost him before. Not learning lessons is dumb.

Branch is just dumb. His conduct proves it.

I heard she is?

Cheryl Miller was unstoppable in every phase of the game…scoring, shooting, defense, good passer out of the post.

Comparatively, she was Hakeem. She was voted last year to the women’s all time collegiate starting 5. Knee injury robbed her of a pro career but she crushed at the Olympics and other international stuff in college. First athelete, male or female to be HS All American 4 times.

She bad.

3 Likes

Branch is targeting our main players

OK, fair enough. Clearly you’re not moving off of this one. It was a dumb play, I agree, but I don’t think it makes him a dumb person.

Honestly if you told me a Lions player suffers a horrible neck injury yesterday before the game. I would have guessed Branch. He definitely uses his head to spear. Great way to seriously injure yourself or others.

5 Likes

He needs to stop leading with his head and trying to make every hit look like a highlight reel. Love the guy but come on man.

2 Likes

Nope, not moving.

Thinking Clearly Under Pressure (TCUP) is what differentiates good from great in all walks of life. Branch does not think clearly in the moment, he just launches himself without thinking. This kind of stuff would make me wary of giving him a contract.

So, Zidane’s headbutt, “Manny being Manny” Ramirez, Jim Marshall running the wrong way, Larry Walker handing a live ball to a fan (Rickey Henderson constantly losing track of how many outs there were), Josh Allen/Brett Favre’s many boneheaded picks? Even Magic Johnson dribbled the ball out when the game was tied without ever shooting in the finals one year, they lost in OT, Ray Lewis’s dumbass late hit against Kordell Stewart, on and on and on. That all means they weren’t great?

You are being too black and white about this imo.

Dumb and stupid players can be great, but it’s always in spite of said dumbness or stupidity.

We should also keep in mind the distinction between dumb and stupid, a distinction that generally becomes apparent in 7th grade. I don’t think Branch has been dumb, which to me indicates decisions made out of ignorance (which may or may not be inherently correctable), but rather he’s been stupid – he’s obviously capable of learning, and is certainly not ignorant, so he’s exercising a complete lack of wisdom; he should know better, and is capable of knowing better.

I can agree that he has made a couple of stupid plays in the heat of the moment (but also, to his credit, some very smart ones), I just reacted to the idea that people who make dumb mistakes during a high-intensity moment are inherently dumb. I don’t believe that.

Well, there’s two kinds of dumb. Dumbness is borne of ignorance. Those who can learn don’t make dumb mistakes again (unless they’re stupid). The dumberer ones, though, just can’t learn.