In the vein of the other two threads about “most hated” and “coulda been” players, I thought it might be fun to reminisce about the “never was” players - the guys who, for whatever reason, were draft or preseason favorites that we as fans counted on (for little to no reason) to develop who never really materialized.
David Kircus is a good example.
My favorite for this category is Ronnell “The Hammer” Lewis. Lots of people loved him as a draft choice and projected him to contribute for several years, even when he never really showed anything on the field.
Who’s your favorite “never was” guy?