If I’m trying to win it all this year I take Allen bc of the QB run game wrinkle. Long term it has to be Herbert who has more upside as a passer.
Herbert, and it is an easy choice for me. He is bigger, faster, better rating in college and NFL, and has more poise. Allen is a really good option though. Herbert threw for more TDs in his 1st year than Allen did in his first two seasons.