This could be an interesting excercise. Who are you higher on than consensus, and who are you lower on? For me:
Higher:
- Arnold Ebiketie - I have him as my 4th ranked edge just behind Jermaine Johnson and in my overall top ten.
- Alec Pierce - He needs to get more physical against press but otherwise I struggle to find many weaknesses, he’s still got a lot of untapped potential.
- George Karlaftis - I didn’t think I’d be one of his backers because I had him firmly in the teens back in January when he was going in the top 5/10. But now he’s going in the twenties/round 2 and I still have him firmly in the teens, so here we are.
- Jalyn Armour-Davis - Kind of got lost in the shuffle at Alabama due to untimely injuries before finally working his way back up the depth chart. Best football ahead of him.
- Malcolm Rodriguez - Great athlete, leader, allowed fewest receptions of any LB in college football last year (in the pass-happy Big 12). Wrestling background mitigates for his smallish-size (5’11, 232) in traffic.
Lower:
- Jordan Davis - IF he can play his entire career at 330/340 then I’m probably gonna be wrong on this one, but to me that’s a big ask. To me the most important trait a prospect can have is professionalism, and I worry a lot Davis doesn’t have it. Why did it take him until after his final year at Georgia to finally lose the weight?
- Trevor Penning - He’s mastered the art of looking like a tough guy but has lumbering feet which to me makes him almost undraftable.
- Boye Mafe - I’m always a little worried about pass rushers without instincts. Yes, he’s got the athleticism you can coach up and he’s tough enough, but to me it really caps his ceiling.
- George Pickens - This is tough for me because I really liked his tape, but the more I look into him, the more I think he’s your classic diva WR, and I don’t really want any part of those.
- Evan Neal - I don’t think he’ll fail outright - guys his size rarely do - but I don’t think he’s the prospect everyone’s making him out to be. He’s got good explosion and straight-line athleticism, but laterally he lumbers. He’s definitely better served on the right side.