This offseason the Lions looked to Spielman as a voice of reason and knowledge. I have always seen and respected his knowledge, passion and accountability. What I have always seen from most position players is that they do not understand the intricate issues regarding other positions and take their mentality into positions that don’t fit. Spielman has shown he understands the keys most players should be looking for that tell them where the play is going and what their responsibilities are. Whether that translates to all positions or just some is the question.
When the Lions had Rathman as the RB coach, they charged him with finding the best RB in the draft. He came back with Kevin Jones, who had the mentality (or got it from Rathman) of a FB. I remember debating with Wesleysh as I preferred Steven Jackson, who was a sure bet in my mind as big RB’s who can also catch the ball match up well with the multi DB defenses in today’s passing game. To be fair Jones played well his rookie year, but the problem was that he always looked to hit defenders instead of run around them as he wasn’t nearly as elusive. That was the FB’s mentality you do not want in a RB. We saw it again with Marinelli taking Kevin Smith over Jamaal Charles, who was a unique talent. There are many positions where a LB’s mentality isn’t what you want. Campbell is certainly the mentality Spielman likes as a HC. Will we see these types of mistakes in other positions where “tough guy” isn’t the focus? Hopefully Holmes is the voice of reason to overrule tough guy over best player!