Whats your all time nfl players

QB - has to be Brady
RB1 - Barry
RB 2 - Thurman Thomas
WR - Moss
WR - Fitzgerald
TE - Gronk
OL - Sewell
DL - Ngata
DE - White
LB - LT
CB - Revis
S - Ed Reed
K - Hanson… consistent and longevity
P - Fox

1 Like

Great topic @Martymcfly2017
So many great players in this thread, most of whom I was able to watch.
Looking at who I chose then seeing other players show up and like, wow, I didn’t think of him he was great. Thurman Thomas, Kellen Winslow Sr, Ronnie Lott, the Lbackers, and more.

2 Likes

One qb- Montana
Two rb because everyone will pick barry- Peyton
Two wr- Magatron & Jerry Rice
One te- Tony Gonzalez
One oline- Alex Karras
One dt - Warren Sapp
One de- Jared Allen
One lb - Butkus
One cb - Deon Sanders
One S - Troy Polamalu
And one kicker- Blanda

1 Like

If I did a homer list for WR, he would have been near the top. #87 was a stud until he got nailed on a crossing route. Defense could lay the wood back then.

1 Like

Marino QB
Barry Sanders RB
Earl Campbell RB
Randy Moss WR
Jerry Rice WR
Anthony Munoz OT (John Hannah)
Mean Joe Greene DT
Bruce Smith (basically a tie with Reggie White) DE
Luke Kuechly MLB
Primetime CB
Ronnie Lott S

1 Like

One qb: Jim Harbaugh
Two rb : Butch Woolfolk, Harlan Huckleby
Two wr: Anthony Carter, Desmond Howard
One te: Jake Butt
One oline: John Elliott
One dt: Mo Hurst
One de: Curtis Greer
One lb: Larry Foote
One cb: Charles Woodson
One S: Jabrill Peppers
And one kicker: Ali Haji-Sheikh

1 Like

@Rugbylion658 great call on Ngata!

Lawrence Taylor
Guy McIntyre
Randle McDaniel
Barry Sanders
Chris Doleman
Lester Hayes
Howie Long
Marcus Allen
Mark May
Kellen Winslow
Dan Fouts

just to name a few

1 Like

K- Mike Lantry

I see what you did there…

any pattern you see is entirely coincidental

My favorite track athlete is Bob Ufer who set the world indoor record for the 440 in 1943

1 Like

Darren Sproles! Loved that dude

QB Roger Staubach
RB Barry and Greg Pruit
WR CJ and St Brown
TE Ozzie Newsome
OL Bill Fralic
DT Joe Greene
DE Al Baker
LB Robert Brazille
CB Ken Riley
S Jack Tatum

2 Likes

One qb Peyton Manning - loved watching him operate (Brady, Fouts, Marino, Bradshaw…all in the mix) Lots of QBs I have enjoyed watching
Two rb Walter and Earl Campbell
Two wr Moss and Amon
One te Winslow
One oline Sewell
One dt Suh
One de White
One lb Taylor unless he is a DE then Ray Lewis
One cb Woodson
One S Reed
And one kicker Janikowski

These are just off the top of my head players I loved watching. The list is long and could all change tomorrow. Troy for safety or Lott…I mean depends on my mood.

Also, I have always felt like Woodson is under appreciated. I have stated for some time that I think he is one of the top 10 football players of all time. Unbelievable athlete and player.

3 Likes