The #1 GM

I’m fairly certain this might disappoint a couple people :clinking_beer_mugs:

11 Likes

Larry David Hbo GIF by Curb Your Enthusiasm

6 Likes

Get me a Super Bowl ring and I’ll shut up about him.

(By the way, I do like Brad. But I love Dan).

7 Likes

@Nate You have a big enough heart to love them both. :clinking_beer_mugs:
SB incoming, just a matter of time and injury luck!

8 Likes

Yeah I mean it is a weird discussion.

I have this kind of debate all the time on Tom Izzo.

25+ years of solid teams and 1 Natty

On one hand I am like he needs to win another Natty. But also he has somehow kept the Spartans BB team relevant even with the shit show of the BOT and the revolving AD situation and President situation over those 25 years.

I have to settle on the belief that I prefer the Izzo model over the cycle of win Natty and then suck completely. But it is one of the reasons I like Howie in Philly. And he is poised to rebuild that franchise in this next draft

3 Likes

Games started seems like an odd metric to use. How was the performance in those starts. Should be the delta of EPA compared to EPA of those picks historically. Surplus EPA in the GMs draft.

Now frame it from 2024. How you like him now?

Brad Holmes hasn’t drafted a good player since Brian Branch

It is law

2 Likes

Kind of weird because you get all the way down to Green Bay at 16 and wonder how they got rated there when they show goose eggs across the entire ledger. They’ve got nothing from their drafts that have even sniffed the pro bowl.

1 Like

Brad is bald. Someone here should like him alot just for that reason!

2 Likes

If Dan Campbell shaves his head. Natty might need medical attention. :grinning_face:

4 Likes

As bad as 2024 is perceived, it really was a decent draft.
Vaki is a great ST player and blossoming as RB#2, Hog at LT looks like he might become a PB LG and Rakestraw is showing signs of becoming a starter in the secondary.
Any draft that can get you 3 starters within 3 years is considered a great draft.
2025= Tate, Tyleik, & Ike. More to come.
LOVE the 26 draft: Starting RT Miller, Derrick Moore, SGH, Rolder and there will be a couple more plus starters that show up down the road from this draft.

To answer your question, I LOVE what this bald beautiful man is building!

6 Likes

I’m shocked to see Jerry Jones that high.

1 Like

I’m the opposite. I love Brad and like Dan. I think I like Dan personally more than I like him as a head coach. I’d rather have Ben.

But but but…….he traded away some day three picks to move up and get players? Why isn’t his disregard for these magic beans weighted into this?

1 Like

He’s definitely the best drafting GM in the league… People have a problem with him not spending big in FA or making the blockbuster trades… He’s elite, no matter what anyone says

5 Likes

I think Jerry defers the draft selections to a committee.
Thankfully his specialty is hiring the HC. :sweat_smile:

3 Likes

I think that’s getting way too granular with a metric that just isn’t high-fidelity for individual players to begin with. I know the football analytics community wants this to be like WAR is for baseball, but the nature of the game makes it impossible to get the kind of discrete data points that one can get in the one-on-one matchups with baseball. It’s like putting an 8-bit game on a huge projection 4K TV and then standing 2 feet in front of it to see the detail.

I think there’s some combination of things like overall record, awards/recognition for the players, counting stats, games started, minutes played, etc. It’s always going to be a matter of triangulation, and there can’t help but be some subjectivity to how to weigh different aspects.

In the end, there’s a lot of work to try to approximate the eye test with a number.

2 Likes

Facts Fake News GIF by Cabin 9 Films

Brad Holmes is the type of man that makes women want to leave their husbands… Turns straight men gay… Turns lesbians to wanting the bald guy… Children look up to him, men want to be him

You get the idea

PS… Fire Brad :fire:

3 Likes