There's a new #1 Minor League Prospect; He's a Tiger

Clark moves up to 13 from 31
Briceno and Rainer also in top 50

Full article at link

McGonigle has “the best hit tool projection we’ve seen in a hot minute,” BP prospect evaluators Jarrett Seidler and Jefferey Paternostro wrote while praising his offensive profile.

“McGonigle this year is carrying an 84% overall contact rate and a 10% strikeout rate,” they continued. “He hits the ball hard more consistently than anyone on this list. He hits the ball to good parts of the stadium. He makes great swing decisions.”

Expert MLB daily picks: Unique MLB betting insights only at USA TODAY

McGonigle was promoted to Double-A Erie on July 7 after tearing up High-A West Michigan in 2025. In 36 games for the Whitecaps, McGonigle slashed .372/.462/.648 with seven home runs and 39 RBI in 171 plate appearances, earning a spot in the 2025 MLB All-Star Futures Game.

========

center fielder Max Clark, the No. 3 overall pick who came in at No. 13 on the midseason list, with BP writing: “It’s not hard to squint and see Clark being driven in 100 times a year by McGonigle, Greene, and Torkelson in a couple years.”

15 Likes

Lets Dance Space GIF

5 Likes

Never in a million years would I have thought that McGonigle would end up being the #1 prospect.

Props to Harris.

3 Likes

# Hot prospects Clark, McGonigle, Briceno get first taste of Tigers training at Erie
Full article at link

===

“In high-A, there are a lot of arms that have true stuff,” Graham said, talking about the distinction in skill McGonigle, Clark, and Briceno will steadily see. “These guys up here have more of an idea how to pitch. They’re in the zone more consistently. They can land more pitches in pitcher’s counts.

“They’ll exploit and find weaknesses.”

Timetables for Detroit?

Far from being certain. The percentage guess: All three will get summer-long Double A baptisms before heading, at some point early next year, to Triple A Toledo.

Their road to Detroit figures to be short. And perhaps in McGonigle’s case, given his position and exceptionally mature bat, earlier rather than later is a defensible thought

======
Graham’s take on each of the three:

:arrow_forward: McGonigle: “His first four games he didn’t have the results, but you could tell it was going to come. He’s so aggressive at the plate, and in the heart of the zone — not chasing.”

His play at shortstop?

“Everyone’s got some stuff to work on,” Graham said, “but he’s doing a good job. Just has to get more confident with his posture when he throws.”

Max Clark of the Detroit Tigers runs to first base in the third inning during the 2025 All-Star Futures Game at Truist Park on July 12, 2025 in Atlanta.

Max Clark of the Detroit Tigers runs to first base in the third inning during the 2025 All-Star Futures Game at Truist Park on July 12, 2025 in Atlanta. Jamie Squire, Getty Images

:arrow_forward: Clark, who plays center field: “He’s come in here and hit two pull-side homers, so it’s good to see him pull the ball with authority (his Saturday night would-be double was another indicator). That’s something I hadn’t seen previously. And he’s doing a good job patrolling and directing in the outfield. He’s working to eliminate the chase (swinging at pitches out of the zone) a little bit, and that’s just the speed of the game up here.”

:arrow_forward: Briceno, the 6-foot-4 probable and eventual full-time first baseman who is still getting part-time work at catcher: “Good, soft hands,” said Graham, a one-time Tigers catching prospect before turning to managing. “He has that big body and I was the same height, so I can relate. It’s a little easier being on knees (compared with the old squat-only catching style). He has a good arm. We’re shortening up his release, allowing him to get through the ball quicker.”

McGonigle next month turns 21. Briceno’s 21st birthday is in September, Clark’s in December. Their three-season minor league hitting data to date:

:arrow_forward: McGonigle: .324/.423/.496/.919.

:arrow_forward: Briceno: .284/.380/.478/.859.

:arrow_forward: Clark: .273/.392/.421/.813.

From the above article, a few others.

=====

Peck ‘wildly overlooked’

His glove, his arm – Tigers scouts knew they were big-league-grade when John Peck was drafted, seventh round in 2023, from Pepperdine University.

His right-handed bat – that would be the question, as often it is with slick infielders whose defense outshines their plate-punch.

But notice this guy, Peck, playing mostly shortstop at high-A West Michigan: .311 batting average in 77 games, .370 on-base, .460 slugging, .830 OPS, with nine home runs.

…Peck turned 23 on Friday and was fine in a 49-game 2024 tune-up at low-A Lakeland (.249/.348/.373/.721). He had slightly better numbers during an 18-game cameo late last summer with the Whitecaps.
What you see in 2025 is a man 6-foot, 180 pounds, getting stronger, as that slugging percentage, higher OPS, and nine homers imply.
What you also see, not as inspiring: His walk-rate in 2025 is a lightweight 7.8%. He strikes out 27.2% of his at-bats.
An organization big on strike-zone ethos will want improvement there.

“I think for John the strikeout-rate is what it is, but he’s also hitting .310,” Cappuccilli said of stats that applied after Friday’s game. “We don’t over-pump batting average anymore, but if the strikeout rate is high and the batting average is .310, not .260, it’s easy to say we can try to minimize the punchouts.

“But what does that come with?

“If he becomes passive because he’s worrying about strikeouts, we’re eliminating his ability to drive the ball. We want him to be aggressive. You want guys disciplined at the plate, yes, and hitting balls in the big part of the zone. And I think he’s done that.

=======

Short hops

:arrow_forward: Cappuccilli on third baseman/first baseman Izzac Pacheco, the Tigers’ second-round pick in 2022, who is batting .278/.407/.498/.905 and, who, like Peck, has some issues with strikeouts (29.1%):

“I think there are similarities,” the skipper said. “I think it’s easy to dissect guys and pick and choose numbers. But I think he’s close to, or at, career-highs in homers and doubles, and he’s playing good defense. He’s another guy who’s hitting for high average, and driving the ball, and not a lot of guys who do those things have low strikeout rates. You want to see guys put the ball in play. But you want them also to drive balls in play.”

:arrow_forward: How long before Troy Melton moves from Toledo to either a Tigers rotation or bullpen job? In his last three games, Melton, who is right-handed, has thrown 15.2 innings, been nicked for nine hits and no runs, while walking three and striking out 23. Melton is 24 and, of course, was a Tigers fourth-round pick (2022) from San Diego State. He is an hour away from Comerica Park – and, in the context of his work and the Tigers’ needs, perhaps even closer.

2 Likes

# Tigers’ Kevin McGonigle – now top prospect in baseball – learning how to block trade noise
full article at link.

==
“So he’s got a very, very competitive personality,” Graham said. “He’s a joker. I give him some (teasing), he gives it right back in a respectful way, which is good. I like that, too. So he’s got a personality that fits in really well in professional baseball.”

The key to all of it for any player is the professional part. McGonigle admitted he liked seeing his name at the top of a prospect list, but he had to be sure he didn’t pay too much attention to it.

“It’s a pretty cool thing to see, but I don’t really dig too deep into that stuff,” he said. “I never have, from high school till now.

“I just try to stay away from it and, you know, I don’t want that stuff to get in my head, and I don’t like thinking too much about it. So just try to go out and play baseball the same way I’ve always played.”

======

“I don’t look too deep in that stuff,” McGonigle told the Free Press Sunday, July 27, before he went 2-for-4 with two doubles and two RBIs against Somerset. “I’m sure there’s stuff out there on social media with my name involved and all that, but it’s all fake news.

“So I’m just looking forward to staying with the Tigers and helping them win a World Series one day.”

McGonigle won’t turn 21 until Aug. 18, but he has a mature presence about him that belies his age. He knows outside distractions that he can’t control, like trade rumors, won’t help him. That’s part of the maturity Graham, who managed him in 2023 and 2024 with the Class-A Lakeland Flying Tigers, has noticed during their reunion.

====

McGonigle has only played 12 games in Double-A since he was promoted July 6, 2025 from High-A West Michigan, where he showed power and patience on his way to 1.110 OPS. Now he’s facing more consistent pitchers and deeper bullpens, but he’s still producing, with an .828 OPS, five doubles and a home run in 44 at-bats.

“I would just say the pitching is a little bit better,” McGonigle said, “and I feel like pitchers in High-A might miss the zone a little bit more than the pitchers here in Double-A. The game’s a little bit faster, too, which I’ve adjusted to. It took about a game or two to get used to.

“But again, I don’t think it was that big of a jump, and I’m looking forward to keep getting better, better at this level.”

Graham noticed McGonigle being a little too aggressive at the plate when he first arrived. But then most top-40 picks, like McGonigle was out of high school, are aggressive. Pitchers in Double-A aren’t throwing McGonigle a lot of fastballs, which has led to him chasing off-speed pitches out of the strike zone.

“That’s his floor right now,” Graham said, “which is an easy fix for him, because he’s always had a great swing-decision score, meaning he doesn’t chase too much.

“So it’s just more of him becoming a little more passive, because he’s an aggressive hitter, and the best hitters are. They’re aggressive. You make a mistake early, doesn’t matter what count, he’s going to explode on it.”

1 Like

We all know some women who can relate. Amirite?

2 Likes

KRYPTONIAN

2 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 90 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.