What hope is there for the Lions defense?

The hope that we dont have Deshaun Watson at QB

2 Likes

3 Likes

From the article:

"Another reason Campbell has hope is that they can finally dig into correcting the film. Prior to Thursday, Campbell admitted the short week really prevented them from correcting their errors made against the Saints in Week 1. With another set of data points and a long weekend to digest and self-diagnose, they can really start the big adjustments.

“Now we can really digest—okay, this is our two-game snapshot, this is what you are, this says what you are,” Campbell said. “And we can really deep-dive these players, what they do best, what they don’t do or need help in, and we’ll move on from that.”

This is why I didn’t think the Lions had a chance against Buffalo. The Lions basically changed over their defense in the offseason. Under AG, the focus was big bodies to stop the run, forcing teams to pass. The secondary exclusively played man coverage, and basically chased guys around hoping to force difficult throws and to cover long enough for the front 4 to get home.

This offseason, I think the Lions did finally acknowledge that giving a QB 5 seconds to throw is a bad thing. The guys we signed and drafted, make it look like the Lions want the defense to be lighter and faster in the front 7. For the secondary, they are trying to rely on confusion and disguising looks to make the QB hold the ball a little longer and give time for the pressure front to get home. You saw this in the preseason, and the first half of the Saints game.

One thing I love about football, there is ALWAYS a counter. Here is our achilles heel. Our secondary has no idea what their responsibilities are. Sheppard is so worried about tricking the offense, that our own guys are the ones who are tricked. You can argue that we don’t have the talent on the back and and I won’t disagree, but you are seeing multiple guys chasing the wrong guy. That’s not talent, it’s scheme and guys not understanding the assignment. Talent is the guy was in the right spot, the offensive player just ran past him, out jumped him, etc. A defender nowhere on screen? That’s a completely different issue.

Basically, the first half of the Saints game was what this defense can look like when it’s working. Then after we went up 21-0, that’s what the defense will look like once you figure out where the weakness is. Sheppard definitely went to the well way too many times with the nickel blitz. In baseball terms, Sheppard was throwing fastballs, and was happy to be throwing them past Shough. Once Shough started timing up the fastballs though, he went from strikeouts to homeruns. That’s why you constantly have to change up your looks and change up your timing. Even guys who throw 100 can get timed up.

Getting to the original point, the Saints found the Lions achilles heel and hit it hard. I watched the All 22 video on the defense, and he called it out early. The Lions defenders do not know who to cover. Normally what you would do is go to film study, figure out what was happening during the breakdowns, come up with a plan to try to cover what you can and use practice to make sure guys are getting to the right spot. However for this week, we had zero time to do this. The Lions didn’t even practice this week. Every problem we had against the Saints, is now going to be magnified by going against a much better QB who also can run as an added twist. This was a recipe for disaster and that’s what happened.

The Lions now have 10 days and 2 games worth of film to sit down and figure out why no one can figure out where they are supposed to be. Either the scheme is too complicated, or guys are going to need to lose playing time who can’t be in the right spot. I said before I thought this season might start out looking ugly, and it has looked uglier than I thought. However, in the NFL, it’s not shocking that teams will hit you hard with it. It’s also not shocking that you can turn those things around. That’s why every year we see a team get blown out, then bounce back. We will see if the Lions can do that, otherwise it’s going to be a very long year because that defense is completely lost.

12 Likes

Completely agree and well written/thought out. Maybe I’m just in a ‘mood’ today, but I have little faith in Shep and Dan Campbell on that side of the ball to get it right. That’s why I’m so irritated. A better d-coordinator gets the most out of our talent, and that is NOT happening. I’ll say it until I’m blue in the face, we don’t have the overall talent on that side of the ball to be a top 10 unit. But middle to slightly above average is more than achievable. I have little faith in Dan or Shep on knowing HOW to get the defense right again.

5 Likes

the only problem is, since this is basically almost a ‘bye’ is we aren’t good coming out of a bye for whatever reason.

I feel bad for dan but our SB window is closed. He was super accurate when he said ‘that might be our only shot’ after the frisco game where we absolutely stepped on our dicks.

3 Likes

Here’s my broad brush opinion on it, just going by things Campbell has said over the years and judging how he has handled things. @maggie.m was pointing this out in the game chat as well.

I think Dan is an offensive guy, shocker I know, he played TE. So that’s why you see a big focus on offense for the Lions, that’s the side of the ball he knows most. I think when it comes to defense, he basically just trusts the defense to be handled by the coordinator and for the most part is very hands off of it. This is not abnormal, a lot of coaches do this to some capacity. I think this is why you see Dan blame the offense a lot, even when it’s blatantly clear the defense is the one not holding their end of the deal. In fact, I was surprised Dan finally brought up that the defense was not getting it done.

I think the other part of it is, Dan wants to give young guys chances at a coordinator job, because that’s what he had that helped him. I think Dan can be too empathetic to guys who were cast off of teams due to injuries, because that was his whole career. Dan wants to be the guy who gave you your shot at redemption, and it’s extremely admirable but it also comes with a cost. For every happy story, there are just as many sad ones.

I 100% think if Dan wants to run the team as wanting to be as hands off the defense as possible, he has got to find an old vet DC. Not give a young guy a chance to cut his teeth and learn through the school of hard knocks, he needs to find a DC with a lot of experience who meshes with Dan’s personality. I just don’t see that happening though.

I hate the expression, to me that’s defeatist. If Bald Holmes goes out and makes 3 big trades on defense or whatever, and the Lions come out firing for the rest of the year, “OMG we are SO back!” So the window went from closed, to wide open in a day? Fickle damn window! The “window” is a media invention so they can say what teams they want to win, and what teams they don’t.

8 Likes

Im watching the highlights and of course i pause it on 1st and 10 right after we score Josh Allen rolls out we have 5 guys in the area it is Josh Allen and 2 TEs

White has the TE in front of him and he is trying to catch up to him

Barnes cutting off Josh Allen’s run lane to the outside

Lacy right next to Barnes running the same way as Barnes almost in a attempt to block him like he is a O Lineman

Tyliek is chasing after the other TE

Reed is face guarding the TE that White is trying to catch up to and not even looking at Allen

We have allen cornered and he jukes like he hit the button on Madden, Lacy and Barnes trip and Allen runs for a 8 yard gain

All 5 look so lost on the play

8 Likes

I was watching a play and you see Reed come crashing down, then immediately turn and run full sprint back the other direction. It’s not the first time that’s happened, or it’s happened to him. That tells me the guy is lost. He doesn’t know what he is supposed to be doing and is changing his mind midplay. That shouldn’t be happening, and not only is it happening, it’s happening frequently. It’s a mess.

Good news? It’s correctable with time and experience. Bad news? You can easily still have the talent problem. So imagine the Lions spend 10 days and get all of the assignment issues ironed out. It’s perfect world, but go with it. Now, you play the games and even though everyone is in the right spots, they are still getting beat. Yeah, you not ONLY had an assignment and scheme issue, NOW you confirmed you have a talent issue. Yeah, things can actually get worse.

6 Likes

You have all training camp to put these guys in a position to know where they’re supposed to be. And they don’t know. So what were they doing in training camp facing super vanilla offenses so that they could learn the scheme? That’s fine but then you have to start throwing reality at them from a standpoint of what are you’ll actually be seeing from offenses.

But that’s really just an excuse because they were just fine through two and a half quarters in New Orleans and then lost their flipping Minds for the rest of that game in the first half of the Buffalo game. That is on Shep.

What we didn’t need was another first time coordinator where the learning curve is Seasons long when the window was open right then and we’ve got all our guys in the prime. It was a bad hire not because Shep is or isn’t a good defensive coordinator it’s because he’s the wrong fit. Especially when a guy like Jim Schwartz ended up being available. Now I know he may not want to come back here and he may not be exactly the guy but that’s the type of guy they needed to hire, not another probationary status tryhard

8 Likes

there is defeatist and realist. I can have the suziest of sunshine attitudes and the lions won’t lose again! but they will. and probably to each of our division mates. twice. We just saw what it was like playing a top tier team and we got stomped. We played a so so new orleans team with a decent defense and almost lost and probably should have.

I’ve watched the games. Seen our preparation or lack thereof. Watched a crap defense get worse. Watched a slightly above average oline become average at best. Our dline is healthy and didn’t do crap last night. Hutch is going to burn himself out he’s great but he’s one guy.

We’re playing like a .500 team. We aren’t even the best team in our own division.

To me, it comes down to expectations.

I’ll keep this one short and sweet. 2022 - 1-6. FIRE DAN! MEATHEAD! FAILURE.
End of the season 9-8, knocked out the Packers, finished 2nd in the division. Hey! We aren’t half bad! We could’ve made the playoffs except for that ugly Carolina game.

So which team was the real Lions? The answer? Both. If you want to declare the window is closed though? Fine. Pack everything up and quit. There’s no sense playing if there is no hope to win. If the window is closed, then you have to start from scratch again and hope you find more lightning in a bottle. I expected this team to be more like the 2022 Lions. It’s going to start rough, but should get better as these guys compete against other NFL teams. Thats what happens when you go with a big changeover.

1 Like

The hope for the defense is getting at least one of our all world safeties back and him being his former self. Even then we’re likely more so below average rather than historically bad.

To me the crazy part about this season is that you’d generally expect all of these blunders to happen in year 1 of a new DC. After a year of learning the DC and system, in theory, it should be a lot smoother. Clearly notbthe case for us.

2 Likes

Go back and watch the 1st half of the saints, Shough missed on a few wide open throws and their receivers dropped a few first downs….they should have put up points if not for shooting their feet

Our defense is struggling bad right now. I don’t see any solutions soon, unless we trade for a corner and make Reed our number 2 and bump Ya Sin to the bench….teams have picked on him regularly, along with our safeties and backers…TE in the 2 games 16 for 187 and 4 TD…Saints between Fant and Johnson 7/87 2 TD the bills with Kincaid and Knox 9/100 and 2 TD.

Pick up Mason Taylor from the Jets for next week

2 Likes

As far as hope. We’ve played the toughest team on our schedule. Outside of Chicago we should be able to outscore most teams.

The problem is we’ll probably finish with a solid record, win the division, get bounced in the 1 round and no real shot at the Super Bowl with this regime.

1 Like

I’ll say it this way. I think this year IS year 1 for Sheppard’s defense. I think last year, Dan made it a big point of emphasis for continuity. That’s why he brought Morton back, to try to run Ben’s offense. He promoted Sheppard, and Sheppard for the most part ran AG’s defense outside of a few wrinkles. As the year wore on, Sheppard did start tweaking the defense more mostly due to injuries forcing changes.

I think this offseason, Sheppard had the training wheels fully taken off by Dan and was allowed to make this defense his own creation. We are seeing the rough side of that change over process.

1 Like

This makes sense. Since Dan doesn’t know any of these players, they never had training camp, or practice, and Dan never met them.

No hope with Shep. He’s not good enough… that’s the reality.