NCAA Oversight Committee admits replay protocol was misused in UM-WM game, Western Michigan the rightful winner

Noone can take the win away from Michigan, so you can calm down. Also, this wasn’t something that took time away from Western. Michigan had to make an incredible play to win the game.

That being said, you are missing why this was so controversial. The networks have 2 ways of showing fans the time. One is their own digital time shown in their graphic. The other is literally a live feed from a camera that is pointed directly at the stadium clock. The stadium clock hit 0. You can argue the point all you want, but that is what happened. What we learned was that there is a time mechanism that is “more official" than the main stadium clock that the officials relied upon for the review. That is why this grew legs the way it did.

Lets go ahead and give the NCAA oversight committee the ‘no shit’ award this week.

2 Likes

The play before the first hail Mary, the receiver caught the ball and went down with 11 seconds on the clock, the clock kept rolling until 8 seconds. The refs had the clock put back to 9 seconds and as soon as the ball was hiked the clock went to 8 seconds which means the clock didn’t use 1 second before rolling again or that 9 really means 8 and .999 seconds. So if the clock hits 0, it can be assumed that theres .999 of clock not being shown? Its all very odd.

4 Likes

There is no tenths in college football. Big ten and not uofm is the blame for this mess.

Michigan deserved to lose…duh…

But what people are just ignoring is they gave up a Hail Mary to lose the game. It’s not some great conspiracy that Michigan was awarded an extra second. If the fix were truly in…it doesn’t get to the point of giving them another shot at a prayer lol.

Also, if you are not a WMU fan, just move on with your life. Like who cares

3 Likes

Like the face mask with Rodgers. Were you pissed they gave green bay a extra play? Game was over

Was i pissed? Sure was. Still pathetic to give up an Hail Mary to lose. Also, that’s my team involved…there’s a huge difference.

1 Like

Full circle.

Born bald, ugly duckling phase followed (era of hair), then return to glory by age 25

6 Likes

It is but also pathetic to lose to western Michigan

That live feed pointed at the stadium clock was the one used in the replay. Go back and watch the replay video they put out. You see that P to the right of the clock? That’s the P from penalties that was on the scoreboard graphic.

I guess my main point is, I’m not sure I like that a tv broadcast clock is the go to clock over the actual clock in the stadium.

1 Like

Well it wouldnt be the first time a Big Ten school lost to a MAC school like …IDK…Central Michigan or somebody.

3 Likes

This is a long winded way of saying there’s a lot of people that hate UM because of the Stallions ‘much ado about nothing’, their arrogance, and the Harbaugh era. They wanted to continue the “Michigan cheated” or “Michigan got away with another one” narrative for as long as humanly possible.

If this was an irrelevant program and they came out and said, “well we followed the rule as it was implemented, whether you like it or not,” no one would bat an eyelash. They would say, “that rule is crap and should change, but they did it correctly,” but that’s not the response and we know why.

5 Likes

We are discussing ‘real’ big 10 teams right now.

4 Likes

Toldeo or something or whats that div 2 school they lost to Again?

Damn im glad you can talk this much shit. Mel Tucker went 2-1.

You should honor him by naming an award after him.

Ladies and Gentleman, I give you the Mel Tucker lifetime achievement award.

8 Likes

Is that moore?

5 Likes

Neymar World Cup Trophy GIFThe Tucker Wood Chopper Trophy in breslin center.

1 Like

dumb and dumber GIF

2 Likes