NHL Playoff seeding format complaints: Poll

So ive been seeing a couple of people complaining about the playoff format.

For those that dont know. The NHL is 32 teams. 16 in each conference. 8 in each division.

Since 2014.

Top 3 of each division make the playoffs. With 2 wild card from each conference.

The seeding however is what comes into question.

Each division has its own quadrant. so 1st in division is 1. 2nd in division is 2. 3rd is 3. Where the 4th is one of the wild card teams. Where the highest 1 seed gets the lower wild card team.

Thats what people have an issue with. Especially in the West this year. Because current in the central projected is

1 COL 121pts

2 DAL 114pts

3 MIN 106pts

4 UTA 92pts

Where the pacific

1 ANA 96pts

2 VGK 90pts

3 EDM 89pts

4 LAK 86pts

Meaning Minnesota with 106pts will be a road team. And vegas with 90pts will be a home team.

Virtually making Minnesota a “6 seed” instead of 3rd. And Vegas a 3 seed instead of 6.

But so what. The only difference it makes is the first 2 rounds for 2 matches.

Currently Minnesota would play Dallas in the first round.

If they seeded simply 1-8 Dallas and Minnesota would have an easier game round 1. But they would still meet eachother round 2. So it makes no major difference when you get to the Divisional round.

The NHL playoffs is the most competitive and balanced in the 4 major sports. Id rather have more balanced and divisionally based playoffs.

Vs having major blowouts and chaos.

What does the Den Think?

  • Current Divisional Format
  • 1-8 Conference Format
0 voters

Neither. Make divisions matter.

Top 4 from each division in their own brackets
Winners from each division bracket play each other in the conference finals.
Cup is played by the two conference winners.

Wild cards are stupid in every sport. Focus on divisional play to create intense rivalries. More in-season games against divisional opponents, more divisional playoff series. I want these guys to hate each other.

3 Likes

And if you really want a “wild card”, just make the 4th spot in each division a play-in game between the 4th and 5th place team in a division. Start the NHL playoffs off with a bang.

Thats why i like the current format. Happy median. I would have to look how many years where wild cards came from the dame division.

I guess this year if the Islanders dont make it you would have 5 from the Atlantic and 3 from Metro.

That and keep the wild cards in their division.

Simply just high lighting the fights at 3-5 in the division for the playoffs.

Vs the fights 6-10 in the conference

Again not a major difference, but i like it.

The issue i have with that tho is it would punish good teams in good divisions. You could have a team make the playoffs with 80 points but they are thr 4th best. And a team with 95pts is out because they are 5th

IMNSHO, Small divisions make no sense. not as bad as the NFL though. Winning a four-team division? Woop-de-doo. So what?

I HATE play in games.

Again why the NHL is the best. Hard line 16 teams. 0 byes.

Nfl is close 2nd. And odds are nfl is going to 16 teams soon enough with no byes.

But MLB having 162 games. And STILL having more than 8 teams is criminal.

And NBA dear lord. 82 games. Where most players barely play 60. And you still have 2/3 of the teams in the playoffs.

Thats why i hope NBA & MLB go to 8 teams divisions when they go to 32.

NFL has to go with 4 teams because of scheduling.

Otherwise you would only see the same 7 teams every year.

In the NFL, with an 8 team division, you’d play the other 7 teams once, and then maybe two or three twice. And rotate who you play twice year after year. So half your games would be in-division, andother 3 outside the conference, and the rest would be outside your division based on the place you finished the previous year like today.

1 Like

Happens almost every year in the NFL. We’ve seen teams with a losing record (or 8-8) win a division and get a 4 seed while a 13 win team has to travel. There’s never a perfect scenario.

2 Likes

Exactly happens 1x every 10 years or so. So no reason to blow up the whole system for that.

And NFL i like the home & home in division.

Vs

7 regular games. Makes the division more meaningful

What the real complaint should be. East vs West.

Wing’s projection out at 101 points.

La Kings projected IN with only 86 points.

15 points difference! Largest gap in the cap era


It’s happend three times this decade alone

1 Like

@Richard_Parker

I’ve noticed that you’ve used a screen shot a couple of times to quote. The quote functionality is still there, you just have to slide the top menu to the right to get to the little ‘plus’ drop-down:

Click that, and there will be a menu where you can select ‘Quote whole post’.

Alternatively, you can select a portion of, or the entire post you want to quote, and a little menu will pop up that will allow you to use that in a quote response.

Hope this helps!

Thank you sir but it doesn’t seem to work on my iPhone. If I post from my iPad then it works then. But I’ve been having issues quoting post on my phone. But thanks for you help brother! :100:

1 Like

Time for a new phone!

chris farley my post GIF

1 Like

The amount of screenshots I see on this website where people are not using dark mode is insane. Y’all are psychotic

1 Like

Dark mode feels like 1989 to me.

2 Likes

I was referring to the NHL.

But yes NFL its a tad more frequent.

However the NYG did win the SB

You were? I mean when does the NHL have a sub .500 winner of a division and gets home ice advantage?? When does a NHL team win 13 games and plays on the road in the playoffs?? You were not referencing the NHL…you literally responded to an NFL format but you were talking about the NHL?? Come on man… :shaking_face:

I mean the reason people are complaining.

A team with ~90 points is hosting a series

While a team with ~105 points will be a road team.

They are not playing eachother but still in the same conference.

The NHL it’s impossible for a team with more points than the opponent to be a road team.

That big of a gap has never happened.

But a gap of even 4+ points has only happened 1 other time since rhe new system was put into place. And only 3x total in the cap era.

so people complaining about it this year are just being loud to be loud.