I’ve worked myself into distress at the scenario in which the Jaguars take Hutchinson instead of Neal with the 1OA.
I’m not nearly as sold on Thibodeaux as I am on Hutchinson, and indeed, Thibs seems to be sliding away from the tippy-top of draft boards.
And if there’s nobody willing to trade up, who do the Lions take? Someone like Hamilton or one of the CBs? At 2OA??
This is where several of you tell me it doesn’t matter, that Hamilton is a transformative yadda-yadda-yadda who’s easily worthy of the pick.
Since 2010, no safety has been drafted higher than 5th overall (It may be much longer than that, but that’s as far back as I went.). In that time period, the average pick in all of those drafts for the first safety taken is 27th.
(Though I’ll admit that the three safeties drafted highest in that time period all turned out to be good – Eric Berry 5th, Jamal Adams 6th, Minkah Fitzpatrick 11th.)
The Lions have been stuck on suckitude for many reasons – almost completely whiffing in the second round forever; squandering too many first-round picks on players who didn’t pan out. But one of the reasons is their absolute cluelessness on positional value – the idea that certain positions get taken up high because of their oversized importance – QB, OT, Edge – and because the required financial structure of a roster dictates that those positions take up the most money.
Meanwhile we have the Lions taken tight ends, plural, higher than any other team; the highest-drafted cornerback in a quarter-century.
News flash: Hockenson hasn’t lived up to where he was drafted. Not even close. He has the stats of just another good third-round TE.
And we won’t talk about Okudah. It still disgusts me. He was drafted at a position where you should have expected someone Deion Sanders-like. He displayed none of that, ever, and now he’s wrecked.
What’s particularly galling to me is that in every case, you have these “experts” matter-of-factly talking about how makes perfect sense to draft Okudah 3rd overall; or Hockenson in the top 10.
I’ve become convinced that the teams that always win blow this smoke at these pundits so they’ll go out and infect the minds of incompetent front offices like the Lions have had.
Hutch or trade-down is where I’m at. God help us if neither is an option.