I love this place, but the Stafford and Goff shit has got me rethinking how I chose to spend my time lately…
There was a freaking Taylor Decker restructure thread that mentioned guys like Reiff and Backus, and naturally that turned into Stafford vs Goff somehow.
We have posts comparing pressure in the pocket, and one year Stafford was 2nd in the league and the next awful. Then a post about Goff being #8 in the league under pressure, then the next year he was BAD!!!
- we’ve debated arm strength, leadership, accuracy, Calvin and Tate vs Woods and Kupp etc……
NEWSFLASH- Matt Stafford wanted to leave. Asked to leave…. Between you guys and me, HE ASKED OUT THE PRIOR YEAR…. That’s why the Bloomfield lake house went up for 6M- it wasn’t because they were suddenly worried about kids drowning in a lake, it’s because he was hoping to get Quinn to allow him to seek a trade…. HE WAS DONE LOSING, DONE GET KILLED…. And frankly - IM SURE HE WAS SICK OF HEARING HE WAS PART OF THE PROBLEM ON SPORTSTALK RADIO HERE IN DETROIT, AND EVEN QUESTIONED IN THIS FORUM BY MANY!!!
Stafford was never consistently considered a top 5-6 QB, maybe never once prior to moving to LA…. Clearly a start studded cast of weapons, a solid OL, and great D (that was peaking by the playoffs) was enough resources for Stafford to be a SB WINNER-
-
Stafford is talented as hell
-
Stafford is a great guy
-
Stafford couldn’t win with shitty culture around him
-
Stafford couldn’t win with inferior talent
-
Stafford couldn’t win with bad coaching or scheme
-
STAFFORD WANTED OUT! HE JUSTIFIABLY QUIT DETROIT FELLAS (and ladies). He is GONE BY CHOICE!
————————————————————————-
-
Goff is very talented as well (drafted #1 OA)
-
Goff accomplished more in 5 years than most ever!
-
Goff started losing weapons and OL in 18/19’
-
Goff couldn’t win with inferior talent.
-
Goff was the scapegoat after the team started losing talented pieces and replacing none, and was traded!
-
Goff is here, came here to a worse situation (talent wise) than anything Stafford ever saw on offense. I’d say Kevin Smith, Grew, Northcutt, B Johnson, and CALVIN was better than what we had last year. I’d also say Delmas, Foote, Julian Peterson, Avril,
J Hunter, Sims was similarly bad to what we had last year.
————————————————————————-
This ongoing debate is literally insane. I would venture to bet that 100% of the guys in this forum would prefer to have Stafford as the Lions QB for 2022 of the objective was winning 9 plus games. 100% would take Stafford if they had to bet the over on win total…
There is no debate…NONE! We would all take him, but it’s not happening. It is more likely we end up with Bryce Young, A Rodgers, or TB12 than seeing Stafford back here…. HE WANTED OUT- he didn’t make a sacrifice for us, HE DEMANDED OUT! Then he won a ring- good on him, but lusting over how good he could have been “here” is a lost cause.
————————————————————————-
I watched 12 years of Stafford being on of the highest paid QBs in the history of the league… every year, and us not winning. It’s not that Goff or anyone else would have done better, it’s just that Stafford didn’t work out here either…So in essence-
A) he wanted out
B) we didn’t win with him here
C) see options A and B
————————————————————————-
I was a psych major in college before falling into finance, and still remember a thing or two, but I will ask Natty to weigh in as our resident expert here……
- The lions were not in the right place at the right time for Stafford. A bad GM, and inexperienced HCs who never played the game at a high level we’re trying to WIN BECAUSE OF A ROOKIE QB, NOT WIN WITH ONE!
Either way he’s DETROIT’S ex-wife/girlfriend now and many fans want to keep reminiscing over old pictures, play “anniversary mixed tapes,” and every time we get a little drunk we call and leave 5 messages- “just checking in…” STAFFORD MOVED ON- HE MARRIED AND HAS A BUNCH OF KIDS WITH HIS LA FANS….
- Meet our rebound- his name is Jared Goff. He knew it was long odds when he showed up. He knew we were still hung up on Matt…. He was willing to look past our flaws though… no WRs, broken OL, shitty D… AND WE WONT STOP TALKING ABOUT OUR EX!!!
He’s embraced our city, brought his smoke show fiancé’ here, started giving back to the community, and at the end of the year he even won us a few games…. The rest of the roster loves him, and he seems pretty loyal- why not truly give him a chance?