just to clarify…. you wouldn’t take Skubal out of a tied 1-1 game…
after 6 innings… and then replace him with a rookie RHP….
knowing that Ramirez was due to hit 2nd in the 7th inning….
and knowing Ramirez is hitting .321 against RHP… vs… .265 against LHP… and higher SLG and OPS as well…..
and THEN…… let that rookie RHP pitcher try to throw off-speed pitches on the inside half of the plate to Ramirez???
While not defending Hinch choosing Melton in that situation, Ramirez does well vs Skubal. I’m guessing it was the third time Ramirez was going to face Skubal in that game.
After all, they’d seen the complete reverse of it. Last season’s run was almost incomprehensible. If this collapse concludes without a playoff berth, it’s equally incomprehensible. Last August, the Tigers had a .02% chance of making the playoffs, according to FanGraphs, and went on a 31-13 streak to squeeze in. On Aug. 22 this season, they had a .02% chance of missing the playoffs and have gone 7-18.
==
In July, the Tigers lost 12 of 13 as the trade deadline loomed. When it arrived July 31, they’d recovered to win four straight. Perhaps that brief stretch lulled Scott Harris, president of baseball operations, and Hinch into a false sense of well-being, as they still led the division by eight games.
So Harris went bargain-shopping and added a collection of used arms with ragged records – starters Charlie Morton and Chris Paddack, and relievers Paul Sewald, Rafael Montero, Codi Heuer and Kyle Finnegan. He said he took the conservative approach because he didn’t want to part with the team’s elite prospects in “moves that were going to haunt us for many years to come.”
When the final word is written, that’s what might haunt them. The rotation and bullpen were wracked by injuries, and only one newcomer – Finnegan – has offered much help. Morton, 41, was released after five straight miserable outings.
Hinch and the players keep saying the same things and their stoicism is admirable, but their play doesn’t match their words. We rightly focus on Harris and Hinch, but make no mistake, it’s been a total team collapse.
===
It’s almost unfathomable how suddenly they fallen. Nine days ago, they had a nine-and-a-half game lead in the division. Since then, they’ve gone 1-9 and the Guardians have gone 10-1.
It’s no longer a pennant race; it’s a pennant trudge. Night after night, you expect it to shift, and night after night, Hinch calmly tries to explain what happened, and struggles to do so.
“I know everybody has to be tired of the same answers, and we’re tired of the same results,” Hinch said. “You do everything you can to get a win, and right now it feels like it’s eluding us in so many different ways. We can handle it because we have a good team.”
Total team collapse
The 6-5 loss to the Braves Saturday provided a new cruel twist. Spencer Torkelson clubbed a two-run homer and victory seemed imminent as the Tigers led 5-4 headed to the ninth. They were 75-0 when leading after the eighth inning. Naturally, the Braves pushed across two runs with two outs against normally dependable reliever Will Vest, and the huge crowd mustered mild boos.
So maybe trading the prospects is the short-term answer. And I’m not sure this team is worthy of any “F-ck them draft picks” approach. In fact, I’m sure they’re not. But for god sakes, play those prospects if they’re as good as you claim. We’re playing Sweeney and Jung here. Stop doing that.